PC

Games like Elden Ring that refuse to mark the map

Playze Staff · Nov 20, 2026

Games like Elden Ring that refuse to mark the map

The thing Elden Ring never does is tell you where to go. There is no quest log, no marker on the horizon, and the reward for riding towards a shape in the distance is that the shape turns out to be a real place with a real boss in it. That is the itch, and it is the hardest one to scratch twice: most of the games like Elden Ring that get recommended next copy the combat and quietly put the signposts back. The ones below keep at least one of the three things people actually miss — a world that withholds, a boss list worth grinding at, or a build you can break the rules with — and each gives something up to do it.

Prices read on 20 November 2026, covering our daily readings from 26 September to 13 November 2026. Offers logged before 26 September are left out because our feeds then included accounts, console keys and region-locked keys, so the low shown on a game page can be lower. Live prices sit on each game page.
GameCo-op?LowDateStore
Dark Souls IIIYes, online$21.811 OctCJS CD Keys
Nioh 2 CompleteYes, online$14.7912 OctLoaded
Elden Ring NightreignYes, 3-player$25.8313 NovYUPLAY
Remnant IIYes, 3-player$3.6716 OctEneba
Hollow KnightSolo only$8.2526 SepEneba
Another Crab's TreasureSolo only$3.2430 OctKinguin
Monster Hunter: WorldYes, online$5.0325 OctEneba

A mounted Tarnished riding across open ground in Elden Ring

Nothing on this list hands you a horse and a continent at once. Several hand you one of the two. (Official Steam screenshot)

Games like Elden Ring where a Site of Grace is the only mercy

Dark Souls III

The case for this one is structural rather than sentimental: the stamina bar, the weapon arts, the roll timing and the estus-for-grace economy all transfer directly, so your muscle memory arrives intact. What changes is the geometry. Instead of a continent with legacy dungeons buried in it, Lothric is one long descending chain of areas that fold back on each other, which means the exploration is vertical and compressed rather than horizontal and optional. You will rarely wonder what to do next; you will often wonder how you are supposed to survive what is next. The Loadout, reviewing the same shortlist, calls it the most direct next step for anyone who wants the weapon builds and stamina management preserved. Worth knowing before you start: Dark Souls III is the most consistently priced thing on this page, and the one game here where our record shows the cheapest offer moving in a range of several dollars rather than cents. FromSoftware's difficulty here is also less negotiable — there are no Spirit Ashes to lean on, only the summoning of other players.

Nioh 2

Team Ninja's answer to the same question is to make the fighting itself a much larger project. Nioh 2 runs on stances — high, mid and low, switched mid-combo — plus Ki Pulse, which recovers stamina if you time a button to the end of your own flurry. Elden Ring's build variety is wide; this is deep in a narrower channel, and the loot volume is closer to a Diablo game than a Souls one. The cost is the map: missions are picked from a menu rather than ridden to. Set in Sengoku-era Japan against yokai rather than demigods, Nioh 2's Complete Edition bundles all three expansions, which matters because the base campaign's last third leans on them for gear.

A knight facing a large enemy in a ruined hall in Dark Souls III

Lothric descends rather than spreads, which is the whole trade. (Official Steam screenshot)

Spirit Ashes traded for actual people

Elden Ring Nightreign

FromSoftware's own answer to "what else is there" is a standalone game in the same universe that reimagines the core design, and the reimagining is drastic: three Nightfarers drop into the land of Limveld, get two in-game days to level and loot, and then fight one of the Nightlords. Everything that made Elden Ring a hundred-hour commitment — the horse, the map, the questlines you ruin by accident — is compressed into a run of roughly forty minutes. What survives is the boss design and the panic. Each of the eight Nightfarers has a passive, a skill and an ultimate, so build choice happens in the character select screen instead of over thirty hours of stat points. It is the closest thing here to the feeling of a first Elden Ring boss, and the furthest from the feeling of a first Elden Ring afternoon: the discovery is gone, because Limveld rearranges itself and you are never lost in it for long. Nightreign is also the most expensive thing on this page in our record, which is unusual for a game built around repetition.

Remnant II

Gunfire Games asked what a soulslike built around firearms looks like, and the answer holds up: dodge rolls, stamina, bonfire-equivalents, god-like bosses, but you are shooting. Its structure is a set of separate worlds whose layouts are partly generated, so two players rarely see the same dungeon. Three people can run the whole campaign together, which is more than Elden Ring's drop-in summoning allows. Our record has Remnant II at the cheapest low of any full-size game here.

Erdtree light, flattened into two dimensions

Hollow Knight

Take away the third dimension and the thing that survives is exactly the part most lists forget: Hallownest is a single interconnected map that genuinely refuses to explain itself. There are no quest markers, the fast travel is something you discover, and whole regions exist that you can finish the game without entering — which is the Elden Ring relationship with its own map, rendered in hand-drawn 2D. The combat is a nail and a dodge rather than a build, though charms let you bias towards poise, damage or healing in a way that rhymes with talismans. Difficulty is front-loaded differently: the early hours are harsher than Limgrave, the late hours less punishing than Leyndell. Hollow Knight is the only solo-only pick here where that feels like a design decision rather than a limitation, and our readings on it have moved by less than half a dollar across the whole window.

The Knight exploring a cavern in Hollow Knight

Hallownest withholds in the same way Limgrave does, at a tenth of the scale. (Official Steam screenshot)

Another Crab's Treasure

A hermit crab hunting for a replacement shell is not the pitch anyone expects after the Lands Between, but the shells are the mechanic: each one is a found object with its own durability and moveset. Steam lists adjustable difficulty on it, which makes this the one entry on the page that answers the question people actually type after finishing Elden Ring — whether there is a version of this that asks less. Another Crab's Treasure is also short enough to finish in a weekend.

Elden Ring Rise, Tarnished official launch trailer

The original launch trailer, from BANDAI NAMCO Europe's channel.

A hunter facing a large monster in Monster Hunter World

Fourteen weapon classes, and no continent to lose them in. (Official Steam screenshot)

Runes for carves, and a boss list that repeats on purpose

Monster Hunter: World

Strip Elden Ring down to its boss encounters and you have most of a Monster Hunter game: long fights against something enormous, learned by failure, where the reward is a material that becomes the gear for the next one. Capcom's version has no overworld to get lost in and no story to speak of, and the fourteen weapon classes take longer to understand than any Elden Ring build. Monster Hunter: World carries the Open World tag on Steam, but its maps are hunting grounds you load into, not a continent.

Which one to put Torrent away for

Dark Souls III, and not narrowly. It is the one game here where everything you learned in the Lands Between still applies on the first try, and the only compromise it asks is that you stop choosing your own direction. Start there, then take Nightreign if what you actually miss is the bosses rather than the riding, or Hollow Knight if it is the map that kept you up. Our beginner's guide to whether Elden Ring is worth it and the Elden Ring versus Baldur's Gate 3 comparison are worth a look if you are still deciding between the open-world and party-RPG routes, and our roundup of soulslikes on PC ranks the wider field. One name that leads most shortlists is missing from the table above. Dragon's Dogma 2, widely called the nearest thing to Elden Ring's sense of a long and unplanned journey, sits at 62% in the Steam review figure our data holds, under the bar we use for a recommendation. On price, the only steady thing in our window is Hollow Knight — its highest and lowest readings are within half a dollar of each other, so no cheaper moment is coming on it. The seed itself, and every live seller we track, is on the Elden Ring price page.

We wrote this from store pages, published reviews and our own price record, not from playing each game for this piece. Some store links on our game pages are affiliate links, so playze may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the conversation.

No comments yet. Be the first to comment.