Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy

Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy

Broken Arrow Games · 2020 · Free to Play, Adventure, Horror, Singleplayer, Violent

PC
Very Positive90% · 8851playing now
This game is free to play. Get it on Steam →

Screenshots

About Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy

✦ AI summary

Play as young Jamie, a kidnapped child trapped in a madman's dark cellar who must solve puzzles, uncover fragmented memories, and outsmart a sadistic psychopath to escape alive. This psychological horror adventure forces you to grow up fast as you navigate a twisted property filled with nightmarish secrets and terrifying encounters that will reshape everything you thought you knew.


"The First Toy" is a standalone story that shares a word with “Don’t Be Afraid” , a horror adventure game.

Take on the role of a child, and try to survive in the terrifying property of the psychopathic kidnapper. Keep your cool to get out of the madman's clutches. Nothing is as it seems here, but don't be afraid...unless you already are?

Your name is Jamie, you are young boy and this story will completely change your life.
If you survive...

You wake up in a terribly dark cellar, surrounded on all sides by terrifying noises and strange unknown items that you didn't even dream of in your nightmares. You are vulnerable and completely alone. Shreds of memories, without any logical connections, flash inside your head. Is someone detaining you? How did you get here?

With every step you make, you will get further from your innocent past. The frightening truth awaits.

The fate of an victim is sealed once it is in the hands of a sadistic psychopath.
If you want to survive, grow up. Quickly.

  • Take on the role of a child and see how he sees the world,
  • Find the notes describing the story and find out who is responsible for your kidnapping,
  • Survive a clash with a terrifying psycho,
  • Solve the riddles that will get you out,
  • Try to escape the psychopathic killer.

What Steam players say

Recent verbatim reviews from Steam — separate from playze.io community reviews below.

Recommended Jun 29, 2026
niceeeeeee
Recommended Jun 28, 2026
Просто предыстория.
Recommended Jun 24, 2026
5.2 I played this after the full game of "Don't be Afraid" to see if it was just like the first level or so, It is but it isn't. I'm assuming it's an earlier build of the first and second level with some differences. This one does lean into a little more of a 'jumpscare' nature with a lot of the spooks being turning around and having a mannequin suddenly in your face. That isn't bad per se but it is interesting that the main game doesn't really feature that to this extend, some mannequins and such move when you aren't looking sure, but this has them directly behind and close etc. The puzzles ARE a little different on the whole, similar but different. So even after playing the main game roughly 4 times which was still at least a somewhat fresh experience. Kind of just 'more of the game' I guess. It does feature a different MC which is also part of the narrative in the main game too, so also nice of it to add a little bit of context there. A noticeable difference being the voice acting, I don't really think that the original Franklin is bad by any means but the main game's VA brought a whole lot of character to the character which changes it quite drastically, both positive …
Recommended Jun 14, 2026
Very good game
Recommended Jun 6, 2026
The game has a strong premise in hiding from your capturer and escaping a basement. Although short, it did make you jump and try to figure out some puzzles. Basement has some good creepiness. Storyline covers a tough topic. Interesting to see the next game that is the sequel. Would recommend. https://youtu.be/qq7C7WZ-uGQ
Recommended May 29, 2026
Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy is a low-budget survival horror show where the main goal isn't fighting monsters but surviving your own panic. The atmosphere is dark and tense, and it managed to make me suspicious even at the sound of a door opening slightly. The horror atmosphere is quite creepy, and the puzzles are quite brain-teasing. The gameplay feels stiff at times, and there are moments that are more confusing than scary. It feels like watching a horror movie that's half serious, half forgetting what it's supposed to be about. Relating this game to the real world, it's akin to life at the end of the month, where the lights are dim, the atmosphere is tense, and every notification makes your heart race with fear of the bill coming. In conclusion, this isn't the best horror game of all time, but it's quite fun for those who enjoy a tense atmosphere without having to think too hard. At the very least, after playing this, you'll realize that running away from problems is the most universal sport.

Community reviews

0 reviews

Sign in to write a review.

No reviews yet. Be the first to review this game.

More like Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy